
Margaret Thatcher made the saying ‘There is no alternative’ (TINA) famous in the 1980s and we have pretty much believed it ever since. She referred to neo-liberalism, our current model of economics that there is no alternative to. Privatisation? Just common sense. Deregulation? Inevitable. Cutting taxes on wealth? Economic necessity. Weakening trade unions? Modernisation. Chasing Gross Domestic Product and growth forever? Well, what else could an economy possibly be for?!
The Irish Development Education Association (IDEA) in collaboration with Financial Justice Ireland and the Centre for Global Education recently ran a training for educators titled There is No Alternative-Or Is There?
to explore how we make economics into our Education for Sustainable Development and Global Citizenship Education work.
We spent the first part of the day looking at the damage that TINA has progressively done over the last 50 years and the second part of the day realising ‘hang on, there are plenty of alternatives’!
There is No Alternative!
Economics has long been seen as inaccessible to those who are not economists and therefore us humans have believed that there is no alternative for many years now which is one of the many reasons why we have allowed our current model of economics to get so out of control. ‘What is economics at the end of the day but household management’ in fact Margaret Thatcher said it herself.
A model and belief in economic growth at all costs (watch the Impossible Hamster with your learners to explain this) and increasing corporate power has brought about the demise of employment and environmental rights and laws further bringing to the point where climate change is compromising our planet and people to the brink of existence. That being only one of the 9 planetary boundaries we have pushed out to a dangerous level. Of most concern to global citizenship educators is the extraction and exploitation of the Global South that goes hand and hand with neo-liberalism often called Imperialist Appropriation. This is best described in Jason Hickel’s research showing for example that 12 billion tons of raw materials travel between the Global South to the Global North each year and 188 million person-years of labour are exploited. Despite what we are led to believe for every $1 that goes to the Global South in aid, $30 comes back out in Imperialist Appropriation, unfair trade and tax rules and unfair debt.
At the training, Conor McCabe and Óisín Gilmore gave an overview of the effects of TINA on our people and planet.
Óisín Gilmore author of TASC Report Inequality in Ireland 2026 brought some shocking statistics on the effect of our current model of economics on the people of Ireland including an increase in homelessness of 437%! ‘In July 2014, the number of adults in local authority emergency accommodation was 3,258. By June 2026:17,482 people’.
Conor McCabe reminded us ‘Capitalism transforms human labour and nature into money forms through violence and coercion’ . He also reminded us of the importance for us as educators to meet people where they are at when talking about the political economy and remember our Frierian roots-referring to Paulo Freire the Brazilian educator who continues to be an inspiration to global citizenship educators.
There are Plenty of Alternatives!
In the afternoon we explored with Davie Philip of Cloughjordan Eco-Village and Meaghan Carmody some of the models and strategies that have been emerging and working to ensure people and the planet are at the centre of economics.
One of the consequences of the TINA mentality is the decimation of community so many of the strategies at play involve community capacity and wealth building.
Here’s four examples of living working examples of better ways of doing economics.
- Doughnut Economics, developed by economist Kate Raworth, reimagines economics to address 21st-century challenges such as social inequality and environmental degradation i.e climate change etc. The inner ring represents the social foundation, ensuring that everyone has access to essentials like food, water, healthcare, education, and equity, like the sustainable development goals while the outer ring represents the ecological ceiling, the planetary boundaries that must not be exceeded to avoid environmental collapse.
The space between these two boundaries—the doughnut itself—is called the “safe and just space for humanity”, where societies can thrive sustainably without leaving anyone behind or overshooting the Earth’s ecological limits. Doughnut Economics challenges your GDP growth, advocating instead for regenerative and distributive economic systems that prioritize social justice and ecological health. Amsterdam is now a doughnut city! So it’s already happening in real life!! Practical applications include guiding cities, businesses, and governments to reduce carbon emissions, ensure equal access to resources, not affecting the planet, while looking after our human wellbeing. There’s good education resources available on the DEAL website to explore Doughnut Economics with your learners.
- The Wellbeing Economy looks at the purpose economics differently: instead of maximizing profit, it aims to improve quality of life, reduce inequality, strengthen communities, and regenerate the environment responding to today’s “polycrisis” of climate, social, and economic challenges
There are great examples of this on a local, national and global scale at the Wellbeing Economy Alliance website.
- Buen Vivir, meaning “living well” or “the good life,” is an Andean indigenous philosophy emphasizing harmony with community, nature, and spiritual balance rather than material accumulation. Buen Vivir originates from the Quechua term Sumak Kawsay in Ecuador and the Aymara term Suma Qamaña in Bolivia, which more literally translate to “the plentiful life” or “living well” In these indigenous worldviews, life is understood as a holistic system where humans, nature (Pachamama), and the cosmos are interconnected. The philosophy emphasizes collective well-being, solidarity, and ethical responsibility, rather than individual achievement or economic growth
- Degrowth is an economic and social movement that emphasizes shrinking rather than expanding economies to reduce environmental impact and promote social equity It challenges the conventional focus on gross domestic product (GDP) growth as the primary measure of progress, arguing that continuous growth under modern capitalism leads to ecological degradation and is not necessary for improving human living standards The idea has been around for years emerged in the 1970s, originating in France decroissance
Degrowth policies can include:
- Reducing consumption and purchasing fewer goods
- Utilizing existing housing rather than constructing new buildings
- Promoting local food production and sustainable agriculture
- Implementing taxes on goods with high social or environmental costs
- Encouraging shorter workweeks and ecologically sustainable employment
These measures aim to stabilise economies while reducing ecological pressures and improving quality of life.
These models and strategies have made their welcome way into curricula in the formal and non-formal sector. In post-primary settings, there are mentions of the circular economy including Leaving Certificate Business and should be explicit in the new Economics curriculum whose specification is being drafted and open for comment until January 2027.
These movements and ideas will be celebrated and explored at a week-long conference/festival in Cork in August 2027 called Go Leor.
We have an obligation as educators to debunk the myth that There is No Alternative (TINA) and embrace TAPA-There are Plenty of Alternatives. As educators, we must be proactive and promote learning about how economics work and the alternatives that promote a fairer and more sustainable world if for nothing else, hope.
There are plenty of educational resources at our finger tips to explore economic justice with our learners-a good start is
Financial Justice Ireland | Home Page .
This link ‘Margaret Thatcher’ will lead you to a satirical educational video on the above content.
Related Articles
Related Articles














